concert review: theatrical song recital

[calimac]

The weather forecasts had led me to expect a heavy downpour when we returned from Stanford at 9 pm, but not a trace of rain. We'd headed out to the large lounge facing the foyer of one of the older Stanford dorms for a concert by an ensemble billed in the Music Department calendar as "Students of Music 183C: The Interpretation of Musical Theatre Repertoire." It was easy to get to, it fit our interests, so we went, although I think we must have been the only off-campus attendees.

Seven students each sang two or three songs in the damp acoustics, accompanied by their professor at the piano. You don't expect much from an undergraduate class; still, one would like heart-throbbing ballads like "Somewhere" or "I Dreamed a Dream" to be rendered with a little less wispy mousiness. And there was plenty of stuff like landing on your high note and then skidding around until you find the right pitch. But the one male student, though his intonation could use help, had a great sense of stage presence. The singer who tackled "Think of Me" from Phantom nailed the cadenza (better than Sarah Brightman, said B., though that's not a high bar *meow*), and the other one who sang "Vanilla Ice Cream," surely the best song in She Loves Me, was wonderful in pitch, projection, and character, with her smartphone standing in for Amalia's letterpad. Overall, a worthwhile hour out.

Comments

[oracne]

And hey, you provided Audience Vibes. A true public service.

[wild_patience]

Re "Think of Me," I meant the entire thing was better than anything Sarah Brightman sang. This is where Phantom really becomes unbelievable, at least when SB sang it. She is replacing the company soprano, who is a real operatically trained singer with the timbre and vibrato associated with such. When they ask SB to sing it to see if she can do the role, she not only sings it in a lower key, she sings it like a pop singer with a straight tone which would never project in a traditional opera house. You would never lower the key (hello, orchestra players?) and substitute an opera singer with a pop singer.