I know that Tircuit has been through a lot and I don't like to dismiss him out of hand; however, I will never be able to trust his reviews since he made that horrible error of judgment (I bet it was 20 years ago) by panning a performance he did not attend (proved by the fact that he particularly criticized the performance of a dancer who was injured and did not dance).

I'm more interested in your opinion, and in Joshua Kosman's (a critic I respect) than in Tircuit's.