2005-10-25

calimac: (Haydn)
2005-10-25 10:42 am

writing reviews

Don't have much to say about a concert of Boccherini and Arriaga except what I put in the review. If either of these names elicit a "who?" from you, you shall be enlightened on the history of Spanish music. In fact, if you saw a certain popular film from a couple years ago, you will have heard some Boccherini. All is explained.

I never know in advance how my public writing is going to go. I rarely write real first drafts: I usually produce a preliminary final draft, and revision consists of infinite polishing with the verbal equivalent of fine-grained sandpaper. This time, though, I got up the morning after the concert and threw 750 words of useless blither at the computer. It gave me my structure and main points, though, and two days later I tore it apart and came up with an 1150-word piece I'm pretty pleased with.

One nice thing about writing about obscure corners of the symphonic repertoire is that I can write more about the music than the performance. It's harder to do that about better-known music without repeating what's been said many times before. Worse still are meaningless biographical nuggets about famous composers. If I have to listen to KDFC tell us once more that Brahms was secretly in love with Clara Schumann, I shall emit a high-pitched whirr.

Meanwhile, I've also written up summaries of the books I found last week at UCB for the Years' Work in Tolkien Studies article. Last year's article was 12,000 words. So far I have 350 words on this year's. It's a start.

Now I'm reading a second Christians' guide to Lord of the Rings, Harry Potter, et al (borrowed via ILL from the library of the college where [livejournal.com profile] sartorias's husband teaches) to go along with the one I already read. They have similar positive views of Tolkien, rather overemphasizing the Christian elements in his work, as if Middle-earth were C.S. Lewis's Narnia. This is standard among such writers now, and one gets almost used to it. But I'd like to get the authors in a room and watch them fight over Harry Potter. One author says Dumbledore shows the Christian virtues of forgiveness and restraint; the other authors are infuriated at the way he lets Harry get away with lying and cheating. All in how you look at it, I suppose.